• Home
  • Contact Us
  • Contributors
  • What We Do
  • Who We Are
  • Case Studies
  • The Cyphers Agency Blog

United Airlines- Too Little, Too Late

Posted in awesome stuff, how NOT to WOM, social media impact. on Thursday, August 20th, 2009 by Andrew Tags: Dave Carroll, social media, United Airlines, United Breaks Guitars, YouTube
Aug 20

Social media empowers companies to connect with customers. It enables companies to listen, respond and promote itself, among a plethora of other things. Social media, however, also empowers customers to get back at brands, as we’ve seen this summer in the United Airline’s “United Breaks Guitars,” debacle.

Last year, when United Airlines’ workers broke musician Dave Carroll’s $3,500 Taylor Guitar, the airline refused to compensate him for the damage. The repairs cost $1,200. In a final offer, Carroll even said he’d accept $1,200 worth of flight vouchers, in compensation for repairs. United Airlines still rejected the offer.

Fed up with nine months of battling with airline representatives, Carroll realized he was not going to win the battle. During his last call to United Airlines, he made a promise to do something that would cost more than the guitar’s worth to company’s reputation.  In fact, some claim that what he did could have cost United Airlines $180 million. His weapon for bringing down United? YouTube.

Not only did the musician use YouTube to trash United’s reputation once, he did it twice. And he plans to do it a third time. His first video now has more than five million views, and the second, released two days ago, has surpassed the 100,o00 mark.

Of course, United contacted him immediately after the first video, offering compensation for the broken guitar. But it was just too late.

There are two important lessons to learn from this.

First, web-savvy customers have the power to use social media just as effectively as big brands do. Two videos can be detrimental to your online reputation. And if the customer causes a big enough stir, the story will get some play time outside of the social media realm.  When Google-searching “United Airlines,” on the first page you’ll see Carroll’s “United Breaks Guitars” videos. On the first page of the “Southwest Airlines” Google search, you’ll find Southwest’s blog “Nuts About Southwest,” which is  highly interactive and an example of outstanding social media execution. Lesson learned? A customer who knows a thing or two about social media can trump your company’s social media efforts.

Second, customer service is still king. With a pretty impressive following of 31,000 on Twitter, and a meager Facebook presence, United Airlines is doing OK on social media. Social media provides a platform for a brand to listen to and interact with customers online. Listening online, though, is not enough. Social media isn’t the end-all be-all. Brands  need to focus on a comprehensive strategy. One that includes social media AND outstanding face-to-face customer service. United Airlines didn’t do that, and now it is the one paying the price. 

Sign in
Livefyre logo
  • Comment help
  • Get Livefyre
Post comment as
twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Trackbacks

  1. The Cyphers Agency says:
    August 20, 2009 at 7:29 pm

    Lessons learned from the United Airline’s "United Breaks Guitars" debacle- http://bit.ly/EXpEv

  2. David Cyphers says:
    August 20, 2009 at 3:29 pm

    Lessons learned from the United Airline’s "United Breaks Guitars" debacle- http://bit.ly/EXpEv

  3. Nancy Carr says:
    August 20, 2009 at 6:04 pm

    RT @adsatTCA: Lessons learned from the United Airline’s "United Breaks Guitars" debacle- http://bit.ly/EXpEv

  4. Sighting: Promoted Tweets | TCA Push N Pull says:
    June 24, 2010 at 2:53 pm

    [...] myself… What are the bigger implications of promoted tweets? Does it take the power away from the voice that Twitter users have?  Does it change the dynamic of the unique online community? Does it disable companies from having [...]

  5. Social Media in Crisis Communication | TCA Push N Pull says:
    August 24, 2010 at 9:17 am

    [...] online crisis can be small or large. It can come in reaction to a customer complaint that goes viral or it can result from a national fear that affects consumption behavior (think swine flu). Either [...]

  6. Doing It Right: Morton's Steakhouse | tcapushnpull.com says:
    August 24, 2011 at 1:19 pm

    [...] even brought to light some occasions where WOM can be detrimental to a company (remember United Breaks Guitars?). Looks like Morton’s Steak House falls under the “social media success” [...]

tcapushnpull.com

  • 888.412.7469

    We are a division of The Cyphers Agency. A division put together to harness the power of consumer conversation.
    read our blog on advertisingSign up for news
  • subscribe via rsslike us on facebookfollow us on twittersee us on flickrwe're linked-in
  • Photo Stream
  • Popular posts
    • Effectively Leveraging Facebook Advertising (Part 1)
    • Word of Mouth Marketing / Social Media Internship
    • Facebook "Like" Button Changes: Straight Wall Abuse
    • Red Cross Turns Twitter Mistake Into Social Media Success
    • Social Media / Word of Mouth Marketing Internship
  • Recent Articles
    • The Next Big Thing In Social Media – Pinterest (Part 3)
    • Starbucks and Little Social Media Wins
    • Smartphones Used by Over Half of US Consumers
    • On-Brand Content Works Best for Facebook
  • Categories
  • Archives
  • Tags
    Annapolis Annapolis Ad Agency Baltimore Sun blogger outreach blogging Branding Breaking News Case Study community management defining your brand digital reputation management Facebook Facebook Ads Facebook advertising foursquare Holidays how to run a contest how to WOM integrated communications Integration JRimbey location-based marketing Mark Zuckerberg Mashable Negative Buzz obama Organic SEO Pinterest PnP Q&A Vlog Project Titan seo social media Social Media for Social Change social media goals social media impact social media marketing social media metrics social media tools Twitter user experience viral marketing WOM word of mouth Word of Mouth Marketing YouTube
  • Review 'Cyphers Agency' with ReviewBiz local SEO tools from BrightLocal.com
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Contributors
  • What We Do
  • Who We Are
  • Case Studies

© Copyright tcapushnpull.com. All rights reserved.
Designed by FTL Wordpress Themes brought to you by Smashing Magazine

Back to Top